An Unlikely Cure for a 9/11 Hero: How Forgiveness Improves Mental and Physical Health

Illustration by The Epoch Times, Getty Images

Epoch Times

Lyndon Harris landed his dream job of a lifetime when he was appointed priest of St. Paul’s Chapel on Wall Street in April 2001. Yet, months later, tragic events would forever alter the course of his life.

Harris lost his home, his wife, and even his health—suffering from PTSD, depression, and lung damage.

He had every right to resent the world and resent he did. What saved him was something unexpected: The power of forgiveness.

From Hero to Victim

Just three blocks from the World Trade Center, Lyndon’s church stood witness to the tragedy of 9/11. The devastation played out before his eyes as the towers fell. In the aftermath, he saw firsthand the human toll: neighbors without homes, families searching for food, and survivors with nowhere to turn.

Faced with people’s overwhelming need, Lyndon set up a makeshift food station, serving hamburgers and hot dogs. Later, he advanced his humanitarian efforts at Ground Zero by helping locals with food drives, providing accommodations, performing last rites, and handing out teddy bears to children–or adults–who sorely needed them.

image-5727608

Lyndon in a robe adorned with emergency services badges, representing solidarity, support, and commemoration. Courtesy of Lyndon Harris

“You see, my mother always taught me that if someone is in trouble, you help them out. And then, if you can, you feed them,” Lyndon recounted.

However, his church’s leadership had other plans. They shifted their focus from humanitarian aid to building preservation. Lyndon pushed back without results, and to his astonishment, church management neither acknowledged nor valued his efforts in helping people.

Months later, Lyndon attended a packed audience at the New York Historical Society to watch a documentary on the ministry of St. Paul’s chapel at Ground Zero, only to find that, as the initiator and the central figure, he was not even in one frame.

It was as if he had been erased. “It was as though nothing I ever did mattered to them,” he said.

While sacrificing eight and a half months at Ground Zero, he incurred damage to his lungs and sinuses—and now a sense of victimhood began to emerge.

Feeling angry and betrayed, he resigned.

“And soon my life began to fall apart,” he recounts. Shortly after, he lost his house and his wife. With an ailing body and mind, he suffered from depression and post-traumatic stress disorder.

His resentment lasted for a decade—he lived in his personal “Ground Zero.”

“Nelson Mandela said it best, ‘Not to forgive is like drinking poison and waiting for your enemies to die from it,’” Lyndon said.

“You know, I drank that poison, and sometimes it tasted really good. And every time I took a sip of that, a part of me died,” he said.

“But,” Lyndon said, “the good news is that’s not the end of the story. My life turned around when I opened my heart to forgiveness.”

How Letting Go Improves Well-Being

Loren Toussaint, professor of psychology at Luther College and a leading forgiveness researcher, told The Epoch Times about a study he conducted with a sample of 1,423 Americans.

The study found that forgiving yourself, forgiving others, and feeling forgiven by God strongly correlated to better mental health, physical health, life satisfaction, and happiness.

Conversely, not being able to forgive, or unforgiveness, has a dramatic negative effect on mental health, leading to rumination and depressive symptoms.

image-5726275

Illustration by The Epoch Times

As the adage goes, “What you focus on grows.” Rumination triggers stress repeatedly and causes a continuous release of cortisol, said Everett Worthington, professor emeritus at Virginia Commonwealth University and author of more than 30 books on forgiveness.

According to a 2019 study, rumination is associated with shorter sleep duration and significantly higher cortisol levels upon waking.

image-5726276

Illustration by The Epoch Times

Cortisol is beneficial in the short term, but over time, it “negatively affect[s] every system in your body,” Worthington explained to The Epoch Times.

Cortisol triggers the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, the body’s alarm system, essential in the fight-or-flight response. However, if hyperactivated, it can harm the cardiovascular system, shrink the hippocampus (where memories are consolidated), and disrupt both the immune and gastrointestinal systems, said Worthington.

Moreover, unforgiveness is significantly associated with higher suicide risks.

“Whenever you’re filled with anger and hatred, quite often you have a diminished desire to even want to live,” said Michael Barry, minister and previous director of pastoral care at the Cancer Treatment Centers of America for 10 years.

The mental shift of embracing forgiveness rather than holding on to a grudge also profoundly influences our physical health.

Toussaint described a telling experiment in which participants recalled a time when someone hurt them.

When recounting a painful experience, you feel a knot in your stomach, your mouth gets cottony, and you start to sweat a little bit, said Toussaint. Although imagined, your brain can’t differentiate, and your body relives the stressful experience.

Participants with forgiving thoughts didn’t have a strong reaction. Their heart rate, blood pressure, and brow muscle tension were lower and more relaxed. Forgiveness prevented them from reacting to hurtful experiences, giving them a muted or “buffered” stress response.

image-5726277

Stress has been linked to an increased risk of major depression, cardiovascular disease, and cancer, with studies showing that stress can alter gene expression, activate inflammatory factors, and contribute to tumor growth and metastasis.

In a study published in the Journal of Health Psychology, Toussaint found that forgivingness significantly buffers lifetime stress, prevents mental illnesses, and improves physical health outcomes.

image-5726278

Illustration by The Epoch Times

According to Toussaint, forgiving individuals tend to employ more effective coping styles for life stressors. They often have a more adaptive repertoire of coping strategies, frequently using problem-focused approaches.

The director of Stanford’s Forgiveness Project, Fred Luskin, explained to The Epoch Times that “the most important impact of forgiveness is the efficacy of knowing you can cope with life.”

In the face of adversity or unfair treatment, you can let go of the past, right your ship, and move forward with greater confidence, he said. By letting go of negative emotions like resentment and fear, individuals gain positive ones such as kindness, love, and compassion, which confer their own health benefits.

Lyndon shared in the interview with The Epoch Times that Luskin, as a forgiveness expert and a friend, often suggested to him that if he devoted as much energy to seeking out life’s blessings as he did dwelling on his misfortunes, he might discover a newfound sense of contentment. This shift in perspective became the cornerstone of Lyndon’s journey toward forgiveness.

Turning the Page

Lyndon shared he had to untangle his victimhood and embrace forgiveness before he could find his way back to health.

Pope Francis declared 2016 a jubilee year—a special year focused on forgiveness and mercy. That same year, Lyndon embarked on a pilgrimage to the Camino de Santiago.

A tradition on the Camino, said Lyndon, is to carry a stone with you and cast it over the cliffs of Finisterre into the sea after completing the long journey to “release the burdens you’ve been carrying.”

Every step along the way, Lyndon thought about his life, past mistakes, and his inability to forgive—and let it all go, he said.

At the end of the journey, Lyndon and his girlfriend Maria, who accompanied him on the pilgrimage, threw their stones over the cliffs. And, “[we] made declarations of intention about our future,” he said. That’s when he proposed to her—and she said—“Yes.”

image-5725190

Lyndon and his [now] wife Maria arrive at the Cathedral of Saint James in Santiago de la Compostela, completing their pilgrimage on the Camino. Courtesy of Lyndon Harris

“I’m a new man with a new mission. I’ve been spared a lot of challenges and a lot of pain. I’ve been so blessed,” said Lyndon.

Lyndon’s mental and physical health is at an all-time high, with no trace of damage to his lungs and no feelings of resentment, he said. He is happily married to the woman of his dreams, and works as a motivational speaker, spreading the benefits of forgiveness.

“All of us encounter tragedy, but we have to find creative ways to respond in order to be happy, resilient, resourceful, life-giving people. And forgiveness is the absolute key to that—without question,” he said.

“The studies are indisputable,” said Lyndon.

The Contour of Forgiveness: What It Is and Isn’t

“Forgiveness is not forgetting,” said Barry, who is also a forgiveness author.

A painful memory consists of two parts: the pain and the memory. Just like a scar on your body, Barry said, “When you forgive someone, the pain goes away, but the memory remains.”

Forgiveness is also not just speaking words, he said.

Barry recounted how a 19-year-old young woman had been estranged from her father for more than six years because of a traumatic experience. She was venting with anger and obviously still in pain. When Barry asked if she had ever thought of forgiving her father, she answered, “I forgave him a long time ago.” Barry suggested she had not.

Forgiveness is “something that truly takes place in your heart,” he added.

Moreover, according to Worthington, it’s important to realize that “forgiveness is within my skin”—it’s a purely interpersonal dynamic—something you do for yourself and not for other people.

Forgiveness and reconciliation are not necessarily “joined at the hip.” You may forgive someone without having to see or interact with them again, he said.

The Playground Principle

Worthington recommends following a framework when trying to forgive; that’s why he created his own forgiveness framework called REACH forgiveness, which has yielded positive results in more than 20 controlled scientific studies, he said.

REACH is: “‘Recall’ the hurt. ‘Empathize’ with the person who hurt you. Give an ‘Altruistic,’ undeserved gift of forgiveness. ‘Commit’ to that forgiveness that you experience emotionally, and ‘Hold’ on to that forgiveness when you doubt,” Worthington explained.

You can apply this framework to major events and minor annoyances, according to Worthington. For example, if someone cuts you off in traffic, you start by recalling the hurt, acknowledging your anger, and deciding it’s not worth staying mad. Next, you empathize by considering that the other driver might have been in a rush or distracted. Then, you offer an altruistic gift by letting it go. If that’s hard to do, you can recall times you’ve been forgiven for similar mistakes. You commit to letting it go and hold onto that forgiveness by reminding yourself later that you chose not to let this minor incident ruin your day.

Luskin advised starting with something small and with people close to you, such as your life partner. Focus on the people who matter and rehearse. Sit for two minutes and practice what you might say to somebody. “Experiment with it,” he said.

The most important thing is the intention to forgive. “Forgiveness is the last stop on the train of healing,” said Luskin. Although teachable and valuable, the specific methods are supplementary, according to Luskin. He referred to Victor Frankl, a Holocaust survivor, who famously said, “Those who have a ‘why’ to live can bear with almost any ‘how.’”

“Be patient,” Toussaint said. He added that you can incorporate calming experiences to foster mindfulness. He recommends prayerfulness, meditation, deep breathing, peaceful imagery, or spending time in nature. These practices help you relax and consider other alternatives to your problems, he said.

Lyndon recommends practicing gratitude, as it’s “the antidote to unforgiveness.”

Barry noted that self-forgiveness takes a similar approach. First, one should make a conscious decision to forgive. Next, accept the wrongdoing committed. Then, show repentance by being willing to correct past actions or behavior. In the third step—which he calls gaining wisdom—ask yourself, “What can I take away from my mistake?”

Lyndon suggests we visualize a playground. Imagine a little kid dangling on the monkey bars. Many of us live life like that child, said Lyndon, stuck in the middle, unable to move forward or let go.

image-5724965

Illustration by The Epoch Times

“You know, how do you move forward?” Lyndon said, “You got to reach toward the future. You got to grab the next bar and at the same time, you got to let go of the one behind you. ”